Are the markets back to normal?
On the second to the last day of February, the US stock market
lost over 3%. Most markets lost 3-4% that day, with international
emerging market equity markets losing around 8%. It was a tough
day.
It wasn’t totally unexpected though, as eventually the market
needed to take a breather. As we have mentioned in past comments,
the stock market has put on an incredible performance of steady
upward price movement since the summer of 2006 without a retracement,
even a small one. In fact, the recent rally in the S&P 500
ranked among the four longest since 1928 that didn’t have
a single 2% correction. Cutting the data another way and using
data on the Dow Jones Industrials, we are currently in the second
longest rally without a 10% correction going back over 100 years.
To re-state, a big loss in the markets last Tuesday wasn’t
the exceptional event; the long rally without any correction was.
Another way to demonstrate that the market has been unusually
placid is to compare its recent volatility to more “typical” levels.
Over the past year (2006), for example, the volatility in the daily
returns of the S&P 500 was 45% less than the over-all volatility
in that index from 1998 to today. Virtually all asset classes and
economic sectors have had drops in volatility (with the exception
of energy, Japanese, and emerging market stocks) since then. It
would not be unexpected to see volatility start to move back towards
typical levels over the course of 2007.
How Does the Market Typically React to Large One-Day Declines?
As many of you know, we update our “Five-Factor Equity Model” early
each month on
www.kobreninsightmanagement.com. Reviewing the five factors,
our outlook remains mostly the same from the prior month: We remain
market agnostics, but err on the side of caution. While additional
declines may be in the tea leaves, we are currently standing pat.
This may have been the beginning of a long overdue correction,
but not necessarily the start of a protracted bear market.
Speaking of tea leaves, and analyzing something which is admittedly
not part of our five factors, how about if we simply analyze last
Tuesday’s price action and what it might mean for the market
moving forward? Can that tell us anything? As with a lot of market
data, it all depends on how you look at it.
On One Hand
On one hand, given the sharp declines from last Tuesday, one could
argue looking at recent data that we could see some above-average
returns for the stock market over the next year. Kobren Insight
Management Research Analyst Ben King collected data on each of
the days over the last 20 years that the S&P lost 3% or more
(34 days) and analyzed what returns looked like over the next
12 months. The average return over the next 12 months was approximately
15% while the median return was almost 20%! The market was positive
nearly 4 out of each 5 times over the next 12 months after a
3% daily loss. So, it’s all good, right?
On The Other Hand
On the other hand, however, what makes this time different is that
the market was simply way overdue for a market correction. Using
data (going back over 100 years) from Morgan Stanley and Ned
Davis Research, we looked at the subsequent declines following
the 19 longest rallies without a 10% decline in the Dow Jones.
The average correction was -16% (median was -13%) with an average
duration of 111 calendar days (the median duration was 81 calendar
days). In other words, it is highly unlikely that last Tuesday
was the extent of the losses.
These two conflicting views of what the decline on Tuesday meant,
gets back to the essence of what we do: build diversified portfolios.
Nobody knows for certain what will happen in the future. The data
can be cut to support nearly every market view. Historical analysis
can provide useful templates, instruction, and warnings, but it
doesn’t predict with precision.
Stay The Course
While some say stocks are currently reasonably valued, that could
change quickly with a shift in the outlook for interest rates,
inflation or earnings growth. Indeed, earnings growth is very
likely to slow in the coming quarters. So, don’t be surprised
if the market corrects further in the months to come. A 10% correction
is long overdue. That said, this is likely not the start of a
new bear market.
Should we see the market correct further, we will not change our
basic strategy but will continue to stay with the diversified portfolios
we have carefully developed to meet each client’s particular
needs and investment objectives. Even in a market environment where
there may be short-term and even violent market moves, portfolios
that are appropriate and reasonable, should do just fine over time.
Sincerely,
Eric M. KobrenRusty Vanneman, CFA
PresidentDirector of Research
Portfolio
ManagerCo-Portfolio Manager
